- Effective property tax rate
- 2.69%
- Median annual property tax bill
- $2,946
- Median home value
- $109,400
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 5-Year Estimates (2019-2023), pulled 2026-09-15.
Cities in Cattaraugus County (20)
- Allegany
- Cattaraugus
- Delevan
- East Randolph
- Ellicottville
- Franklinville
- Gowanda
- Lime Lake
- Limestone
- Little Valley
- Machias
- Olean
- Perrysburg
- Portville
- Randolph
- Salamanca
- South Dayton
- St. Bonaventure
- West Valley
- Weston Mills
Towns in Cattaraugus County (34)
- Allegany
- Ashford
- Carrollton
- Coldspring
- Conewango
- Dayton
- East Otto
- Ellicottville
- Farmersville
- Franklinville
- Freedom
- Great Valley
- Hinsdale
- Humphrey
- Ischua
- Leon
- Little Valley
- Lyndon
- Machias
- Mansfield
- Napoli
- New Albion
- Olean city
- Olean
- Otto
- Perrysburg
- Persia
- Portville
- Randolph
- Red House
- Salamanca city
- Salamanca
- South Valley
- Yorkshire
Other communities in Cattaraugus County (83)
These are named communities within Cattaraugus County recognized by the U.S. Geological Survey's Geographic Names database - unincorporated places, small settlements, and localities without their own city government. The Census Bureau doesn't publish separate property tax figures for places this small, so they're not forgotten, there's just no dedicated data source yet. The county-wide figures above are the closest available estimate for these communities.
- Abbotts
- Ashford Hollow
- Axeville
- Bakerstand
- Baldwin Heights
- Barnum
- Bedford Corners
- Bird
- Boardmanville
- Bowen
- Bradford Junction
- Brooklyn
- Cadiz
- Carroll
- Chipmunk
- Cold Spring
- Cottage
- Crestview
- Devereaux
- East Leon
- East Olean
- Eddyville
- Elkdale
- Elton
- Farmersville Station
- Fitch
- Five Points
- Four Mile
- Fox
- Gardens of Brother Leo
- Glen of Saint Clare
- Harrisburg
- Haskell Flats
- Haydenville
- Homer Hill
- Humphrey Center
- Irvine Mills
- Kill Buck
- Knapp Creek
- Laidlaw
- Lake View Terrace
- Little Rock City
- Machias Junction
- Main Settlement
- Maplehurst
- Maples
- Markhams
- McKinstry Hollow
- Mill Grove
- Nichols Run
- North Olean
- Onoville
- Orlando
- Peth
- Plato
- Pope
- Rays Corners
- Riceville
- Riverside Junction
- Rock City
- Saint Bonaventure
- Sandusky
- Seneca Heights
- Shongo
- Skunks Corner
- Snyders Corners
- South Carrollton
- South Olean
- South Vandalia
- Steamburg
- Sugartown
- The Narrows
- Toll Gate Corner
- Underwood Corner
- Vandalia
- Versailles
- Village of Saint Anthony
- Vollentine
- Wesley
- West Perrysburg
- Westons Mills
- Whiteford Hollow
- Willoughby